Shonda Johnson

Shonda Johnson was born on September 30, 1969. She wasn’t your traditional beauty, but in her small town in Alabama, she was popular.

Shonda Johnson

She dropped out of high school, but told men that didn’t know better that she had been a cheerleader and Homecoming queen.

Despite being unemployed, she often told people that she was a paramedic.

She married Jeff Nelson at just 18 years old. The relationship was tumultuous. Jeff called the police on Shonda more than once. They were divorced after 6 years of marriage.

Her second marriage was to a man named Jimmy Tidwell. This marriage ended in divorce after 5 months.

She married Randy McCullar in 1995. They seemed happy at first, but the couple separated. They did not file for divorce.

Shonda

Just 3 months after the split, Randy heard a rumor that Shonda had married another man named Bill McIntyre. What he didn’t know was that Shonda was pregnant with Randy’s child when she married Bill.

Bill knew she was pregnant and knew it wasn’t his child, but he didn’t care.

Before the couple had been married a year, Bill became very sick. He discovered that he had AIDS. Shonda left him when he was admitted to the hospital in August 1996.

Shonda began living with a man named Ronnie Webb. Shonda became pregnant with Ronnie’s child.

Since she had never divorced Randy, Shonda was a bigamist. Randy filed charges against her in 1997.

Later that year, while still pregnant, Shonda met Tim Richards. The couple married soon after. Again, Tim knew that she was pregnant. He knew the child wasn’t his. What he didn’t know was that Shonda hadn’t divorced either of her two previous husbands.

Tim Richards

Shonda initially lied to Tim. She told him that the marriage between her and Randy had never been legal. Then she told him that Randy raped her. Then she admitted that she was a bigamist and that, if convicted, she would go to prison and lose her children.

She asked Tim to kill Randy. He agreed to do it.

On November 30, 1997, Shonda and Tim flattened one of the tires on Randy’s car outside of a bar where he was drinking.

Randy didn’t realize until he had driven away, with Shonda and Tim following behind, so he stopped in a church parking lot to check the tire. The couple pulled up beside him as Randy began changing his tire.

Shonda handed Tim a rifle and told him to “do it!” Tim shot Randy in the head. The couple drove away and threw the rifle off a bridge into a river.

Randy’s body was found early the next morning.

Randy’s Headstone

Police immediately suspected Shonda and arrested her. She denied planning the murder, but admitted to being in the truck with Tim when he shot Randy.

When Randy heard tapes of Shonda throwing him under the bus, he broke down and told police everything.

Tim took a plea agreement that included testifying against Shonda.

Shonda pled guilty to bigamy and was found guilty of the murder of her third husband. She was sentenced to death.

Ronnie died of AIDS shortly before the murder trial was over.

Tim was sentenced to life with the possibility of parole.

Tim Richards

In April 2012, Tim escaped from a minimum security prison in Alliance, Ohio. Two days later, he was found and returned to prison.

A video summary of this week’s post can be found at

https://youtu.be/5eAjAs-hzeg

If you would like to suggest a topic, please email me at icantbelieveitsnonfiction@gmail.com or leave a comment on this post, my YouTube, Pinterest or Facebook. Thank you for your support!

Sources/Photo Credits

**Thank you Chyna for catching the error in this post. It has been corrected.

6 thoughts on “Shonda Johnson

  1. I think you meant to say Ronnie died of AIDS shortly before the murder trial was over, not Randy. Since he was already dead. ! I love your stories, I’ve been bingeing , keep it up !

    Liked by 1 person

  2. First time learning about this particular story. What a contrast to hear about a
    woman hustling multiple males. Still sad and tragical none the less. Life is to precious to waste it on such deprivation. RIP Randy& Ronnie.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Hahaha, I am laughing because when you said “small town in Alabama” I just knew this was going to be about Jasper. It was considered the “hit man capital of the US” in the 80’s and 90’s and now is eroded by meth problems, a truly miserable racist place. Still have family there. There are other cases to cover there, I’ll try to gather a list.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s